Not enjoying it anymore. It's become a plot-grind, and I'm doing half the grinding.
We're all too scattered out, with HUGE plots resting on the shoulders of TINY groups of players.
I know it's supposed to be all anime-tastic with subplots about pancakes and falling in love, but that's not happening. Sahar and Zion are just a couple of irritating kids with no likeable qualities (unless you're a 12 year old bisexual). I feel nothing for Sahar and I don't want her to win - not one bit. Ryker's knocked out the largest thing in my army with a fucking hand-grenade, so clearly he doesn't want to be challenged in any way. The 00s are all emo loners who seem incapable of advancing the plot in any discernable way (probably because they don't know where they fit in). I'm being upstaged by NPC lolvillains and a frankly unconvincing farmer-turned-high-priest. Yuri has absolutely no support despite being one of the most interesting characters in the story. And the rest is just flashback and conspiracy.
I'd keep playing if there was a radical overhaul of the plot and scope.
For example: The Rebellion is put down and the Norfolkians are driven into exile. Semile becomes an unchallenged dystopia and Sahar is captured with the help of Novacorps. This is the darkest moment for the heroes. The Church plans a ceremony to present Sahar to the people and crown her as Messiah of the New Paradise. AND THIS CEREMONY BECOMES THE FOCUS OF THE REST OF THE PLOT.
Novacorps, of course, have their own agenda. They have helped Sahar to get captured because they want to use her as a weapon, to kill the thousands of humans coming to the ceremony. Setem works this out and realises that it has to be stopped. Dayne and Tobias don't listen to him, of course, so Setem has to form his own rebellion. He draws together a FEW Norfolkian soldiers, Yuri, Altaire and others and infiltrates the ceremony in a tense climax.
Against them are Dayne and the 00s who are still too afraid to oppose him (Jerek, Rhiannon and Eros). Dayne does everything he can to make the ceremony go ahead, despite the High Priest's doubt and the suspicious action of Novacorps.
Everything comes down to one day, one hour - one moment, where Sahar is brought before the people. Will the Church crown her? Will Novacorps unlock her murderous side? Or will the heroes help Sahar to stand again and rally the people against the Church and Novacorps?
A single location. A single premise. A single stake.
With this we can achieve pretty much all the plot outcomes we're looking for, like:
Will Yuri come into his own as a leader?
Will Jerek finally stand up to Dayne?
Will Eros love Dayne until the bitter end, no matter how many die?
Who are Talbot and Miss C and what do they want?
How will the Norfolkians define their place in the new world? Can they really remain as exiles?
Will Altaire give his life for Sahar in the final moments?
Will Heinrich remember something when he comes face-to-face with Dayne?
Will Setem and Rhiannon find a sense of identity?
What lengths will Zion go to to save the one he (apparently) loves?
With tension, stakes and clarity, we can get these character arcs to actually arch. We're supposed to be fucking INFLUENCING Sahar's opinion on humanity, and we can't do that unless we show our true qualities. Only direct conflict, physical and emotional, can make us shine through.
CONFLICT. DRIVEN. NARRATIVE. It cannot be denied.