Well, it seems like the general concept for this is basically rewriting KOTOR without really explaining too much. Don't get me wrong, KOTOR is amazing and I love it (got it on iPad after I found it was on same today, actually), but maybe we need a more solid foundation. Not that free roam/open ended RP's aren't great, but there should be an element of plot surrounding it.
For example: an RP following the stories of multiple people in the Star Wars universe who join up for a greater purpose would be an example of what I would call an "Open-Ended Plot RP", meaning the core idea is there, but we make up the plot as we go along.
The basis for this RP just seems like we're doing a reboot of KOTOR without any real sort of solid structure.