s a m u e l
Elissa not defending Matthew was honestly more shocking than Cameron defending himself. It was just something that didn't happen. Matthew sat completely still. Samuel knew that normally he would have gone after Elissa, because she was crying and he loved her with every fibre of his body, so he would want to make it better. But he didn't, and instead, Samuel noticed something he hadn't seen since they had been to Matthew and Elissa's wedding. Tears were making their way down his cheek. He didn't even seem to notice until some of them fell onto his hands, at which he reached up to feel his wet face and let out a sob and then all of a sudden it wouldn't stop. He let out another couple of sobs and pushed his hand under his glasses to over his eyes as he hunched over.
"I don't want everyone to hate me again," Matthews voice sounded hurt, not bland, not monotone, hurt. It was so odd to hear it filled with so much emotion. Usually, even the times when his voice did hold some more emotion it was a very low-key version of it, but this just full on more emotion than Samuel had ever really seen him display at once.
"Matthew…" Gabi started, clearly conflicted, this had started because he had been judgemental of her boyfriend after all. But Samuel decided he was a little less conflicted since he wasn't really involved, he kissed Letha's head, handed her back to Roman and went to temporarily take Elissa's place next to Matthew.
"No one's going to hate you," Samuel assured him, he didn't know about Cameron but he at least felt like most of their friends had gotten over the thing with Roman and considered Matthew enough part of the group not to shun him.
"Yes, they are. Who do you think they'll choose after this? The guy who keeps stomping on other people's feelings because he can't even read them properly, or the guy whose parents apparently was a million times more disappointed in him than mine are in me and actually can gain people's sympathy," Matthew insisted. Now he sounded scared almost.
He looked up from his hands as he continued, addressing everyone but looking over at Cameron just a little more,
"But do you think I want to be this way? Do you really think I don't feel anything? Do you think I like the fact as soon as it comes down to ripping on me for fun it's about have I don't have any emotions? I do have them, I was just raised not to show them and I don't know how to," He let out another sniffle but adamantly whipped the tears off his face, he was busy making a point, or rather, explaining himself and his actions.
"I've gone my entire life being labelled as some emotionless weird, mean, snob, I grew up without a single friend and if anyone ever bothered to acknowledge me it was to insult me. Gabi was my first friend and we met when I was twenty-two. And then I met Samuel and suddenly there's this whole group of people to hang out with and I fuck it by being me and doing this exact same thing to Roman. But eventually I apologize, and things get better and I meet Elissa. And if it wasn't for her helping everyone see that I'm not an actual psychopath I doubt I would have ever even really been accepted as a part of the group."
Samuel wanted to disagree with that, but it was probably true that his relationship with Elissa had at least helped people see his redeeming traits, which were the traits that had made Samuel stick with him even through all his fighting with Roman.
"And then suddenly you come along. So, put yourself in my shoes for a second," Matthew took a small break to take a deep breath but then continued
, "I have like two things, I'm smart and have a PhD to show for it, and I'm creative and just finally proving my own parents wrong by making it as an author. So imagine what it felt like when someone who is an actual genius and probably knows more than you in the subject you research and who is making it creatively as well. Only this person has charisma and is accepted to the group instantly.
Everything you do feels like a punch in the face. And not only that, but I'm worried about Samuel because not that long before you became a regular member of the group he and I literally talked about how he wasn't sure how to feel about you. And then you're suddenly all over Gabi and she has never been interested in someone in the way she is in you and I just don't understand it. So I got this bad feeling from you, because you seem like you have everything while also taking everything I have from me without even knowing or caring about it.
But I've learnt that my perception is off sometimes So I haven't said anything. And I didn't want to say anything about this or the tour but with Will coming everything has been really stressful and that's just making me more worried for Gabi because how is she going to be able to handle it by herself?" He took another deep breath,
"But yes. Okay. I have no sense of empathy, I'm completely in the wrong for wanting to protect my friend and I'm a shitty person who everyone hates but who cares because it's not like it can hurt me. I don't have any fucking feelings,"
Then he got quiet. He was done. But the tears were still trickling down his face.