I'd probably have to say new. Not that there aren't some vintage ones I like, but I'm a 96 baby and got my first Playstation in... 02? Anything from before 2000 is too old for me to have any nostalgic memories of, and honestly, most of them just don't have all that much to offer except for nostalgia. New games tend to have more features, better plots, more complexity... and they've learned from the mistakes of the past, for the most part.