PUBLIC SERVICE ANNOUNCEMENT Plagiarism: Credit Your Copypasta

Discussion in 'ANNOUNCEMENTS' started by Astaroth, May 6, 2018.

  1. Today's PSA is about plagiarism.

    It's a bit of a loaded word, with some very distasteful connotations, especially on a site dedicated to writing and to written creative content. Since that's our primary concern, we're going to focus on plagiarized text today, although Iwaku's Terms of Service prohibit plagiarism of any kind.

    Plagiarism is ultimately a form of theft. When you think of plagiarism, most of you probably think of cheating on a school paper by buying an essay, or perhaps of someone stealing your story and publishing it under their own name. It's usually accepted that these acts are done by a person with an obvious intent to deceive; they are openly claiming that they have done work which was in fact done by someone else.

    I never said it was mine.

    While the above are examples of plagiarism, it's important to understand exactly what plagiarism is in order to embrace the spirit of anti-plagiarism rules. Plagiarism is, simply, the act of copying another person's creative content without clearly crediting them for what has been copied (unless explicitly given permission to use the content without crediting). Intent is irrelevant. When you pick up a book, it's understood that the story is written by the person listed as the author; even if a single chapter was in fact written by someone else, no one is going to think otherwise unless they are explicitly told.

    What this means is that when you copy and paste information from Wikipedia or from Google's search info or from anywhere on the internet (or transcribe it from printed sources), even if it's just to have the official info available for your Game of Thrones RP or to define what you mean by "kaiju movies", you need to clearly distinguish which words are your own and which aren't. Otherwise, you are breaking Iwaku's rule against plagiarizing--which is one we take VERY seriously. Most cases of plagiarism will simply get you asked to credit your source, but knowingly and intentionally plagiarizing and passing off work as your own will get you a permanent ban.

    But I edited it!

    When talking about plagiarized content in text format, it's important to note that plagiarism doesn't apply only to unaltered chunks of text. Changing names and terms or even just paraphrasing too closely is actually still plagiarism. Let's look at some examples to illustrate what is acceptable and what isn't.

    The above is taken from Jorick's post here in his story, "Goetterdaemmerung". Now, say I wanted to run an RP based on Goetterdaemmerung, but with my own characters. Below is an intended rewrite for my plot info thread, with my changes to Jorick's text bolded.

    If I were to use this text, I would need to credit Jorick for both the RP concept and the text itself, as it is the same with very few changes. (I would also need to get permission since this isn't published anywhere but Iwaku, but that's another story).

    Now, say I wanted to stick more closely to Jorick's canon, including his characters, and used this text instead:

    I've changed sentence structure and paraphrased, making it distinct from the original text, even though I used the same characters and terms. I added a few new sentences to top it off. Guess what though? That's still plagiarism. Let's look at these side-by-side, with some key bolding:

    As you can see, what at first glance might appear to be in my own words is in fact heavily similar to Jorick's text. It is too closely paraphrased and still requires crediting. Some similarities are unavoidable if you're retelling the same events, but it should never read like you just shuffled some words around.

    BOTTOM LINE: DON'T DO THIS WITHOUT CREDITING, EVEN IF IT'S JUST CREDIT TO WIKIPEDIA.

    How do I properly credit?

    We're a recreational roleplaying site and money's not involved here, so it's not like we ask for much. A note following the copied text is sufficient credit. Be as specific as possible about what isn't yours, link if possible, and don't quote content or use unique ideas/terms from other people's roleplays (even if they're from another RP site) without express permission. If it's a roleplay based on a book or movie or webcomic, etc., use the fandom-related thread tags and preferably note it somewhere in your RP info; not everyone may be familiar with the inspiration for your RP. Using quotation marks or the Quote BB Code around chunks of copied text is a good way to define that something is not yours. The Roleplay BB Code is another pretty stylish way to present copied text, like so:

    While Godslayer was indeed powerful, he was finally stopped by a coalition of Immortals who were determined to put an end to the madness. Among them were Jorick, the Witch of the Water, ten others who died in the fight, and a curious fellow known as Speaker of the Dead. Jorick's own account says Speaker of the Dead was vital to the success of their mission, whereas Witch of the Water wrote that he was a dangerous liability that nearly cost them everything. I note this oddity here, and suggest that perhaps the Witch was correct, because Speaker of the Dead plays an important role later on in this history. Returning to the matter of the coalition, they were those among the Immortals challenged to war who had eventually decided to stop trying to use mortals as proxies to fight Godslayer. Instead they infiltrated his fortress home and tried, and failed, to catch him unaware. The fight destroyed the fortress and much around it (locating information is sparse, but there is a lake some thirty miles southeast of Gencha with an abnormally round shoreline that I suspect may be the remaining scar of that battle). Godslayer the Immortal was slain, and Godslayer the weapon was taken by Jorick.


    At the end of the day, just be respectful and make sure you're not leaving room for people to misinterpret and give you undue credit for something you didn't come up with yourself. You wouldn't want someone else getting credit for YOUR writing, would you?
     
    • Useful x 18
    • Love x 3
    • Bucket of Rainbows x 3
    • Thank x 2
    • Like x 1
  2. @Astaroth I have a question now. What grounds does self-plagiarism fall under? Let's say that a person copies and pastes rules from their own RPS or even older character sheets to help recreate a character, using a lot of the original template . Would I need to credit myself on this matter or how exactly would that work?
     
  3. If it's your own content or content that you were given express permission to use without crediting, we don't care. This isn't an academic venue, so using old content isn't a concern. We just care about whose intellectual property it is!
     
    • Like Like x 2
    • Love Love x 1
  4. One of my roleplays has dialogue from a game in there. I've noted in the opening post that posts 2-6 contain dialogue from the specific game. Should my partner and I edit the posts as well and specify which dialogue it is? Would adding something like an asterisk at the end be enough?

    edit: ie I would note in the first post that if dialogue has an * at the end, it is taken from the game.
     
    #4 Greenie, May 6, 2018
    Last edited: May 6, 2018
  5. We're not trying to make people do academic citations or anything. Your first post should be enough of a disclaimer, and if you want to use asterisks to denote the specific lines, that's cool.
     
    • Like Like x 1
    • Love Love x 1
  6. Alrighty, sounds good to me o7
     
  7. I had no idea that we have to credit stuff from places other than roleplay sites and picture services. Thanks for letting us know! So does this mean you have to credit every time you make a post with references in fandom genre roleplays?
     
  8. Nope, as long as the roleplay is clearly labeled a fandom thing then you're fine to reference things from the source material. What we're concerned with here is using text written by someone else, whether an exact copy or somewhat altered, without crediting it. Fo example, having Spider-Man or Captain America in what is clearly a Marvel universe roleplay is fine, but copying and pasting the descriptions of their powers from Wikipedia or a fan site without crediting it would not be okay.
     
    • Useful Useful x 2
  9. Am I being asked to link sources regarding what a kaiju movie is?
     
  10. No, but if you copy and paste a portion of a Wikipedia article about kaiju movies into your roleplay info, you need to credit the text to Wikipedia.
     
  11. "Kaiju movies, according to Dictionary.com, are..."

    This much?
     
  12. Yep, that would work, no need to specifically link to anything as long as you give enough information for someone to find the source if they go looking