The latter. If Satan exists, I want to meet him and tell him that I admire him for having the courage to stand up against his creator, the single most powerful being in the universe, simply because he decided he had a right to not follow. I think everyone has that right. However, if the said god exists, I would rather burn in Hell forever than have anything to do with him; he is a professed enemy of everything I hold dear, and I know that, because I read the bible (for this exact reason: to be prepared for well-informed debate), and it said so with perfect clarity.
(EDIT: but I don't think that either of them exist, this is hypothetical. I delight, however, in the fact that if I turn out to be mistaken somehow, this still puts me on Satan's side.)
Would you rather be rich when young and then lose all your money later by the time you get old, or be poor when young and then become rich when you get old?