- Posting Speed
- Speed of Light
- Writing Levels
- Douche
- Preferred Character Gender
- No Preferences
I remember, back on the original Iwaku, I started a roleplay called Dionysius. It was an erotic thriller. And it was groundbreaking. Nothing of its kind had ever been attempted, and members joined it with a sense of experimental awe and foreboding. They posted their characters and wrote their lines tentatively, glancing at one another and questioning, silently, Can we really do this?
The original Mature Forum was a quiet, ghost-town of a place, where only a handful of members posted the occassional lusty poem or hand-drawn boob. Most of the people who went there were staffers in their 20s and usually made threads with their real-life partners or long-standing friends.
Now....
....
....now we have a plethora of members who have come here specifically to make symbiotic attachments to strangers and play out their twisted fantasies.
Now we have threads where people say "I want to play a girl in a hamster costume! Please post a character that fits with this romantically."
Now we have threads where people dictate the exact plot of their story. "I want to play Harry Potter and he meets Princess Leia and they go to Starbucks and at first he thinks he's gay because he sees a man called Brian who has brown hair, but then Leia takes him to a party and they bond over a joke about a rubber duck and--- AAAARGH!"
Now people don't even make a point of saying "Oh, by the way, it's a one-on-one I'm after." They just wade in on their first post by saying "So, I like to play the dominant one and I only do hetero stuff." This is part of their greeting to the forum.
So, this is not a 30 year old shaking his stick. This is a long-time roleplayer asking, simply, WHEN DID THIS HAPPEN? When did roleplaying suddenly shift into this unspoken agreement that we are here to masturbate? Call me a rose-tinted nostalgic, but it didn't used to be like this. The emphasis was on stories or abilities. People judged a roleplay by what adventures they could have and what power they could achieve.
Now a lot of them judge it by which other players there are and what romantic scenarios they can get themselves into. Some people won't join at all if they don't think there's a compatible cyber-sexual partner.
And that's if you're lucky enough to get smutters in group RPs. The great majority seem content to run into a cave with one other member and then never communicate with the wider forum. Roleplaying has become a back-room, private affair. We're like the club with the sex rooms, where no one really comes to dance anymore.
I mean... do they want other people to read the one-on-ones? Are they playing to an audience? On the few occasions that I've done a one-on-one I've always kept in mind that other people will be reading and I've aimed to make the story audience-friendly. But I'm not even sure if that's a principle anymore.
I know that things change. I also know that it might've always been this way. But it wasn't on Iwaku. Maybe kids in the 2000s did it somewhere else, but they never joined Iwaku to post it publically. So why has it suddenly become so overt? Why is there this unspoken assumption that roleplay is now synonymous with cybersex? Why, with this new generation of roleplayers, do Group Roleplays now seem like the exception to the rule?
In some ways it's positive. The bad Iwaku writers used to be all the teenage boys who came on pretending to be space marines and ninjas. Now at least we have teenage girls coming on to wink and ask redundant questions in the midst of copulation. And yet the emancipation of women should not excuse artistic desecration.
I'm only partially trolling here to provoke debate. A lot of what I've said comes from genuine confusion. It saddens me that the line between escapism and eroticism is blurring. I love porn. It's not the act that I object to. It's the feeling that young roleplayers are treating roleplay and smut as one and the same and are unable to separate the two.
Each is it's own arena of sensation and should remain so.
[By the way, I'm wearing a red leather thong while typing this, and I'm a vampire. If you want to reply to this thread, please play a brunette who likes it rough and wants to go to an Italian restaurant with me at 4pm while exploring lesbian cravings. I don't do dudes, sorry.]
The original Mature Forum was a quiet, ghost-town of a place, where only a handful of members posted the occassional lusty poem or hand-drawn boob. Most of the people who went there were staffers in their 20s and usually made threads with their real-life partners or long-standing friends.
Now....
....
....now we have a plethora of members who have come here specifically to make symbiotic attachments to strangers and play out their twisted fantasies.
Now we have threads where people say "I want to play a girl in a hamster costume! Please post a character that fits with this romantically."
Now we have threads where people dictate the exact plot of their story. "I want to play Harry Potter and he meets Princess Leia and they go to Starbucks and at first he thinks he's gay because he sees a man called Brian who has brown hair, but then Leia takes him to a party and they bond over a joke about a rubber duck and--- AAAARGH!"
Now people don't even make a point of saying "Oh, by the way, it's a one-on-one I'm after." They just wade in on their first post by saying "So, I like to play the dominant one and I only do hetero stuff." This is part of their greeting to the forum.
So, this is not a 30 year old shaking his stick. This is a long-time roleplayer asking, simply, WHEN DID THIS HAPPEN? When did roleplaying suddenly shift into this unspoken agreement that we are here to masturbate? Call me a rose-tinted nostalgic, but it didn't used to be like this. The emphasis was on stories or abilities. People judged a roleplay by what adventures they could have and what power they could achieve.
Now a lot of them judge it by which other players there are and what romantic scenarios they can get themselves into. Some people won't join at all if they don't think there's a compatible cyber-sexual partner.
And that's if you're lucky enough to get smutters in group RPs. The great majority seem content to run into a cave with one other member and then never communicate with the wider forum. Roleplaying has become a back-room, private affair. We're like the club with the sex rooms, where no one really comes to dance anymore.
I mean... do they want other people to read the one-on-ones? Are they playing to an audience? On the few occasions that I've done a one-on-one I've always kept in mind that other people will be reading and I've aimed to make the story audience-friendly. But I'm not even sure if that's a principle anymore.
I know that things change. I also know that it might've always been this way. But it wasn't on Iwaku. Maybe kids in the 2000s did it somewhere else, but they never joined Iwaku to post it publically. So why has it suddenly become so overt? Why is there this unspoken assumption that roleplay is now synonymous with cybersex? Why, with this new generation of roleplayers, do Group Roleplays now seem like the exception to the rule?
In some ways it's positive. The bad Iwaku writers used to be all the teenage boys who came on pretending to be space marines and ninjas. Now at least we have teenage girls coming on to wink and ask redundant questions in the midst of copulation. And yet the emancipation of women should not excuse artistic desecration.
I'm only partially trolling here to provoke debate. A lot of what I've said comes from genuine confusion. It saddens me that the line between escapism and eroticism is blurring. I love porn. It's not the act that I object to. It's the feeling that young roleplayers are treating roleplay and smut as one and the same and are unable to separate the two.
Each is it's own arena of sensation and should remain so.
[By the way, I'm wearing a red leather thong while typing this, and I'm a vampire. If you want to reply to this thread, please play a brunette who likes it rough and wants to go to an Italian restaurant with me at 4pm while exploring lesbian cravings. I don't do dudes, sorry.]