E
EquinoxSol
Guest
Original poster
Real vs. Cover (or Real vs. Acoustic)
We all have our favorite bands, and sometimes that band does a cover of another band. So, here's your challenge (not really). Post two videos here. One is the original of a song you like, the other a cover. Tell us which one you like better! Then, give us a reason! You can't just not like something for the hell of it.
Here's my first one.
Original
Cover
Winner?
Rise Against's original version.
Why?
Because the drummer in Face to Face's version sounds like he is mashing his face against his equipment instead of playing it. Second, the guitarist sounds out of tune and off pitch. Finally, the vocalist is much too smooth and flat to be able to give this song any decent credit. All of this adds up to an overall poor quality sound doing no creditable service to the real band.
Now it's your turn!!
We all have our favorite bands, and sometimes that band does a cover of another band. So, here's your challenge (not really). Post two videos here. One is the original of a song you like, the other a cover. Tell us which one you like better! Then, give us a reason! You can't just not like something for the hell of it.
Here's my first one.
Original
Cover
Winner?
Rise Against's original version.
Why?
Because the drummer in Face to Face's version sounds like he is mashing his face against his equipment instead of playing it. Second, the guitarist sounds out of tune and off pitch. Finally, the vocalist is much too smooth and flat to be able to give this song any decent credit. All of this adds up to an overall poor quality sound doing no creditable service to the real band.
Now it's your turn!!