- Invitation Status
- Posting Speed
- One post per week
- Slow As Molasses
- Preferred Character Gender
- No Preferences
Nooooo no no no no don't look at the TJA list and feel like you can't do anything there. That's not the problem.I looked at the list of TJA races and I can't blame you for getting stuck. Honestly, it feels anything I come up with has already been done, looking at that list. That being said, unique implementation is still unique in the end.
Obviously things like angels, demons, vampires, etc will all very much exist in Omnibus -- I just don't think it's very likely that they'll all play by the exact same rules as their TJA counterparts. But even if they did, that's not a problem. Trying to avoid all ideas just because they may have already been done before is ridiculous, and I really don't want people to look at the TJA list and feel like everything there is off-limits.
My comment about not wanting people to play races from TJA was solely directed at RPers who were actually in TJA. Even more specifically, people who were in TJA for a very long time and created races and characters that became very iconic to what TJA was.
Because, again, I feel like one of the things that led to TJA's downfall was the fact that its lore became increasingly complex over time and that we all became so dependent on these races and characters that losing one of these key members not only shook up so much established lore -- it also made TJA not feel like TJA anymore.
My fear about bringing silvers back has to do with the fact that I was in TJA and silvers were a thing in TJA. And, even if the silvers weren't as iconic as the Observers, the point still remains that I'm the GM, and so me immediately bringing back silvers can set a bad precedent and possibly send a message to other TJA members that they should bring their races back, too -- which is exactly the thing I want to avoid. Not only that, but, just being able to recycle my own TJA race while telling people like Clownpiece that they can't recycle theirs just makes me feel like a hypocrite in general.
And that is the only reason why I feel stuck -- because I just haven't put a lot of thought into a race, and, while many of you here might be recycling ideas from past RP's... my go-to past RP to recycle things from is TJA. Not only that, but a lot of race ideas that I put into TJA were recycled from somewhere else in the first place. o_o" (The silvers, for example, are actually a very old idea that I first came up with when I was like... what, 13? 12?) I have not been looking at the TJA race list and asking myself, "what hasn't been done here?" because that would be dumb and incredibly limiting.
True originality does not exist. Everything that we call "original" is not only made up of a bunch of different existing tropes and was inspired by existing things to begin with -- but it's also very likely that your "original" idea was coincidentally already brought into being by a completely different writer who had nothing to do with you. Even if neither of you "stole" from one another, sometimes coincidences just happen. And being in the digital age just makes us all the more aware of it.
Hell, this is actually why, in the early stages of Altera Arcana, I was not afraid to list everything that inspired the RP and, in some contexts, even explain exactly how all of those things inspired me and how all of those things made it into Altera. Because that's how art works -- we take bits and pieces of things that we like and we put them together in a new way. And that's ok. And worrying too much about being "original" is just so stifling. >~<
*deep breath* Sorry for getting up on a soapbox there for a second, but, yeah... please don't think of the TJA race list as being off-limits. It's ok to take inspiration from what's there. It's ok to re-do some of the more generic races. So long as you aren't straight-up copy/pasting something from the old TJA, you're fine. I just... really don't want you guys to feel limited like that.
The only people who should be worried about re-using TJA races are the people who were in TJA. O_O
Edit: EVEN IF YOUR "ORIGINAL" RACE IDEA IS VERY SIMILAR TO SOMETHING ON TJA'S LIST, THAT'S FINE TOO!!! You're not an actual TJA member re-using an actual TJA race with the iconic name attached, so there's nothing wrong with it. Creative coincidences happen. Please don't feel like you can't do anything vaguely similar to the massive and extensive lore that was TJA.
Edit2: OMNIBUS IS SUPPOSED TO BE A BLANK SLATE THAT BORROWS THE FRAMEWORK FOR TJA ONLY. PLEASE DO NOT FEEL SO ATTACHED TO TJA. WE WANT TO GET AWAY FROM IT. PLEASE IGNORE TJA. >~<"""
Last edited: