P
Prince
Guest
Original poster
I'm deeply offended.Again, I know this is a WIP, so most of this is just requests for the future and giving you information. Don't take it to heart. :D
Alright, changed history stuff. I'm no history buff so yeah, pointing out any historical failures is good. Anyway the "slicing" motion is just imitated by ripping the object instead, like ripping apart a piece of paper. With no hands visible though, it somewhat resembles a "slice." There's no telekinetic sword cutting things apart or whatever, it's more like two opposite pulls on something.@Kaykay You hit me in a personal zone with your character in the sense that you are trying to make her a traditional ninja. Ninja, or shinobi, were mercenaries of the feudal lands of Japan, obviously, but they were mostly contracted for their covert skills. Often times, Shinobi were spies for information, or to steal a single item, or to infiltrate and assassinate an individual, but mostly they were just thieves or sent out for sabotage. Shinobi were known for utilizing the tools around them, not specific weapons, and for literally trying to avoid fighting at all costs. Quite factually, shinobi were often terrible at martial arts and were shrouded in a form of mysticism in how they tried to avoid conflict or being caught. Their tactics, stealth and resourceful nature are what earned them a spot in history; so much so that those of the era believed they had supernatural prowess.
Directly after claiming your character comes from a history of familial shinobi, you claim she is to be trained in advanced martial arts. Martial arts was a very, very small part of being a shinobi; in fact, physical combat was often one of the LAST measures a shinobi would come to. Your entire character, for the most part, speaks about how outdated the shinobi ways were, but in reality, her methods aren't even those of what a true shinobi would be. I only note this because Japanese soldiers, at times, used similar tactics to those of subterfuge by the Shinobi and were even skilled in sword styles, normally diluted samurai variants, for trench warfare. A lot of confirmed kills for Japan were from their stealthy and underhanded tactics as well as their unorthodox training in terms of close range grappling, often involving small hidden pins, knives and assassination techniques imported from eras. There is a historical conflict here that really, really irks me.
This is a major flaw in that your character concept is directly contradicted by historical fact. It's easily mended, though, so I want to highlight what I like. First and foremost, I like the concept of her being a Japanese immigrant. I also like how you incorporate her into organized crime. You have a lot of really great character elements here, as I told Damien he did. I can see a character identity and there is a strong thematic presence here. I just feel it needs tweaked some. The tweaks I have in mind are minor, but before I address them, I want to go over the rest of the CS.
For instance, Damien uses tactile telekinesis. It's a form of close-range telekinesis that requires he envelop an object, item or person in a "blanket" of telekinetic properties before he can manipulate them. What you have here is a type of ranged telekinesis that essentially requires she focus on something to manipulate it. While I understand it, I want some clarification on what this "slicing" you reference is. Do you mean she can cut through objects or that she can produce literal slices? You noted the prerequisite for the ability is an "object of focus" (which is my phrasing for it), so actual slices would obviously be contradictory. Do you mean she is capable of a clean cut through an object? If so, by what means? A strong pull, a force separating the object in its meridian, or what? This is the only real question I have for this. Otherwise, it's fine.
The Wakizashi and Sai are fine for the most part, but you do know a Wakizashi is just a foot-long blade normally used in a single hand by a Samurai, right? They're not traditionally shinobi weapons. Actually, the Sai are. Sai originally were used for planting rice, but made great weapons on the go. As I said, shinobi are meant to be resourceful. I'm fine with both weapons, I just wasn't aware if you knew the specific difference the weapons presented thematically. Anyway, the wakizashi is a plasma-based cutter while the Sai freeze things. It seems simple enough, but I would like just a little more information on the Sai. Ie, how cold can it get? Does it require water? For instance, you can't literally just freeze solid sheets of ice without water. Are you somehow generating water? Just a couple minor questions. Basically, using the cold and generating ice are two different things. You can't make ice without water.
Anyway, so as you seen here, the issues I have with your character fall into two categories: her "shinobi" background and really just wanting more information/clarification. One is simple enough to fix, just write more detail. The former, however, needs a slight rework. First and foremost for the rework, there is essentially logical reason for her to be taught and become proficient at martial arts to preserve a shinobi culture. That's not what their culture was about; it was hardly even a facet of it. Real shinobi were regarded as masters of subtlety, disguise, sleight of hand, resourcefulness, so on and so forth. Shinobi weren't really clans as much as they were mercenaries taught a trade, and shinobi "masters" were those that learned many facets of the trade. Shinobi differed greatly from actual warriors like Samurai; Shinobi weren't even actual warriors. Often times, they were considered dirty, underhanded or even "spirited" people that enlisted dark agents to help them. I would prefer you use these elements to in your character history, and they should fit fine. If she was brought into organized crime in the United States, then all of these skills would basically be perfect. Want to rob a bank? A real Shinobi would be PERFECT for that. Some hand-to-hand combat practitioner with a few stealthy tactics would actually be far less useful. Want to kill someone? A girl that can look like a regular plain-Jane, kill him with a nail from a nearby construction site, then walk off like it is nothing is far more effective than shooting up the restaurant he is eating at. You might have to rewrite some of her younger history, but in the end, it will create a considerably more accurate character. You could even implicate her family into this plot. If she's a criminal and part of an organized crime syndicate, then you could say her family was used as blackmail against her, or that they actually went to America to practice their skills there. If she was offered part of the Omega Squad for these reasons, it would make WAY more sense. She could also receive martial arts training AFTER becoming a member of the Omega Squad, so it's not like she'll be helpless. As a matter of fact, if she doesn't use ranged weapons, she might be the best hand-to-hand on the squad still, not to mention he raw resourcefulness, plus telekinesis and stealth.
Anyway, I wrote a lot because the issue here was a thematic one for the most part, so I really needed to create a firm understanding of how to fix it. It's not really a major issue, but at the same time, it is. It's not hard to fix, either. Still, I wanted to tread with a side of caution 'cause it will cause some significant character alterations. But, what I want to keep in mind here is also what I told Damien: you are meant to fill a niche on the team. You are meant to be stealth, in this case, not stealth, hand-to-hand combat, assassination, infiltration, etc., so it's good to make your central theme a strong one. Damien uses Aviation, Stealth is just as great.
@Damien Kriez I actually hadn't set the precedent for how much "healing" could happen during the process, but I don't see why he couldn't get his legs back. As a matter of fact, I believe that with physical therapy and time, Elric could likely walk entirely again. Since I am allowing this, it will be on the basis that the A'vi DNA wants to passively "fix" the body of its host to be an ideal one, thus while Elric isn't 100% ideal yet, he made it through on willpower and will become ideal again. You can use this as some form of character development, but for now, it's great as it is. Character is accepted.