MAFIA - DAY TIME

Status
Not open for further replies.

Daz

SHSL Torment
Original poster
FOLKLORE MEMBER
Invitation Status
Writing Levels
  1. Adaptable
Preferred Character Gender
  1. No Preferences
This is the day phase discussion area for the Mafia forum game. Here I shall announce who died during the previous night phase and the results of lynching votes, while players may discuss and nominate who they think should be lynched during the day phase.

DEATHS SO FAR:
Night One: No deaths.
Day One: Thatguyinthestore lynched, and revealed to be innocent.
Night Two: Joan

PLEASE DO NOT POST HERE UNTIL I ANNOUNCE THE START OF THE DAY PHASE.
 
Last edited:
The night draws to a close, and the sun rises over your town. You wake up to find nobody has died.

Discussion may now begin. You can nominate any other player to be lynched during this discussion time. Discussion will end at Monday 7:30pm (GMT) unless there is a request to extend discussion time. After that players may vote for which nominated player they want to be lynched.

@Dipper
@Joan
@LuckycoolHawk9
@IntrusivePenDesperateSword
@Kiilgore
@The Tragedy
@Solaresque
@tigertruth
@thatguyinthestore
@Starlighter
 
Well that was weird...

Any preliminary suspicions, folks?
 
Nope, there's little to go by unfortunately.
 
You did it! You did everything!

...Hm? Who? You, of course.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Joan
Yeah I have no clue xD
 
Well, I feel like we have to do something, otherwise the only people who learn anything this phase are the people with night actions...

HMMMM

Yeah I hate it when this happens on the first day :P
 
In the absence of leads though it's pretty much impossible to do anything first night except make a few assumptions.

The fact that nobody died suggests that mafia either didn't order a kill (unlikely), was role-blocked by escort or doctor got lucky and made a successful heal.
 
I GOT IT! IT WAS DAZ IN THE LIBRARY WITH THE -wait..... You mean nobody was murdered...? Oh. My b.

Joking aside,

I think that it's likely the doc option. Otherwise, there'd need to be two roleblockers, and both targeting both maf. (Daz told us the number of maf earlier, On the signup thread.) The chances of that happening are really low. (1/9 each, if there even was a second escort...) Of course, if Daz changed the maf count, then this would be different... *Shrug*

Of course.... (Under the assumption that we stayed at 2 maf, )
Worst case scenarios (mislynches and successful kills.) Would be as follows.
M-T
2-8 today
2-6 tomorrow
2-4 day 3 (Mylo)
2-2 day 4.

If the mafia would have killed someone:

2-7 today
2-5 tomorrow
2-3 day 3 (lylo)

It's almost the same (assuming worst case scenarios that is...).

If the maf wanted to try confuse us or bait out information, so they could try focusing on who to kill, then the sacrifice of that extra person being dead might have been worth it to them. (Bit iffy there, but it is possible....)
 
Well, Daz did tell us that he was still waiting on people and was going to start regardless of them a little before he announced the start, so it's extremely possible not everybody got their turn...
 
I'll confirm that there are TWO mafia and ONE escort, as stated in the other thread.
 
The mafia could be waiting it out though, preferring to take a little time to strategize and not get a lot of attention on themselves the first day.
 
The more time they spend not acting however, the greater their chances of being investigated and rooted out sooner. I'd think it unlikely unless they're simply inactive and missed out on performing their roles. //but I highly doubt it, there being two mafia
 
Makes sense. Forgot we had investigators for a second there.
 
Well, let's break this down...

We have two mafia, one mayor (special role but no night action), three special roles with night actions (escort, doctor, detective), and ten people, so only four of us are normal townspeople, and there are five people with night actions. Daz was still waiting on two night actions at the time the game was supposed to start, and was possibly still waiting on at least one when we started the day phase. For nobody to have died, one of the following scenarios would have to occur...
  • Both mafia went, but one got canceled and the doctor healed their victim.
  • The mafia chose to bide their time.
  • Only one mafia responded and was either blocked by escort or by doctor.
  • Neither mafia responded.

Who hasn't posted here yet? Dipper, LuckycoolHawk9, tigertruth, thatguyinthestore, and Starlighter...

I had someplace I was going with this but I lost my train of thought :P Well, the accumulated information is up there, do what you want with it.
 
Yeah... The investigator is what thrarts the potential of the w8 and b8 thought/strat... (Unless they forgot. But that's going too far into speculation I believe.)

Both mafia went, but one got canceled and the doctor healed their victim.

The doctor would have healed anyways, so the other maf would not need to have been blocked.




Anyways:
From last onlines (at the time of typing this) we have :
dipper, tigertruth as unknown.
Luckycoolhawk: almost 2 hours ago
Thatguyinthestore: 38 min
Starlighter: 13hrs.

Just in case you wanted to see them, because in an earlier game (on a different site.), I used the last online as a way to narrow down the potential maf. And well... It surprisingly worked. Of course... This could mean nothing at all. But never know what use you will get out of things...
 
  • Thank You
Reactions: Joan
Who hasn't posted here yet? Dipper, LuckycoolHawk9, tigertruth, thatguyinthestore, and Starlighter...
Anyways:
From last onlines (at the time of typing this) we have :
dipper, tigertruth as unknown.
Luckycoolhawk: almost 2 hours ago
Thatguyinthestore: 38 min
Starlighter: 13hrs.

Just in case you wanted to see them, because in an earlier game (on a different site.), I used the last online as a way to narrow down the potential maf. And well... It surprisingly worked. Of course... This could mean nothing at all. But never know what use you will get out of things...
I haven't posted simply because I haven't had the time to sit down and think enough about the information available to have anything worth saying. XD

Anyway. From the available information so far, I'm leaning towards the whole 'somebody probably didn't use their night action' theory. I feel like the chances of both mafia being blocked relies a lot on chance and is very highly unlikely, and it just wouldn't make sense for them to bide their time. The goal is to kill off as many townspeople as possible as fast as possible, so that would honestly be kind of a stupid move on their part.

So... as far as who the mafia most likely are, I think the inactivity has the best shot for nominating someone to lynch - we might accidentally lynch someone else with a night action and work against ourselves, but I think it's most likely that at least one of the mafia is in that group. But I don't know, I could be wrong.
 
I need to get involved.

So, what's the deal so far?
 
Yes. If you don't get involved, we might lynch you just because we can. XD

So far this is an idea of what we've got:
We have two mafia, one mayor (special role but no night action), three special roles with night actions (escort, doctor, detective), and ten people, so only four of us are normal townspeople, and there are five people with night actions. Daz was still waiting on two night actions at the time the game was supposed to start, and was possibly still waiting on at least one when we started the day phase. For nobody to have died, one of the following scenarios would have to occur...
  • Both mafia went, but one got canceled and the doctor healed their victim.
  • The mafia chose to bide their time.
  • Only one mafia responded and was either blocked by escort or by doctor.
  • Neither mafia responded.

Who hasn't posted here yet? Dipper, LuckycoolHawk9, tigertruth, thatguyinthestore, and Starlighter...

I had someplace I was going with this but I lost my train of thought :P Well, the accumulated information is up there, do what you want with it.
Yeah... The investigator is what thrarts the potential of the w8 and b8 thought/strat... (Unless they forgot. But that's going too far into speculation I believe.)



The doctor would have healed anyways, so the other maf would not need to have been blocked.




Anyways:
From last onlines (at the time of typing this) we have :
Dipper, tigertruth as unknown.
Luckycoolhawk: almost 2 hours ago
Thatguyinthestore: 38 min
Starlighter: 13hrs.

Just in case you wanted to see them, because in an earlier game (on a different site.), I used the last online as a way to narrow down the potential maf. And well... It surprisingly worked. Of course... This could mean nothing at all. But never know what use you will get out of things...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.