MISC #5 Voting Thread: It's How You Say It.

Which entry do you think should win?


  • Total voters
    17
  • Poll closed .
Welp, I've finished reading all the stories! And though the entries weren't many this time, I once again find myself at odds! I don't know which story/poem to vote for because they're very good. Good thing I have enough time to look over again and make up my mind.
 
Pick mine! :P
 
and I thought we were friends D: I see now, staff and member, that's all it is T.T

;)
 
  • Nice Execution!
Reactions: Greenie
So anyone else have any reviews? :3

I've been writing wee little thoughts, have two left! I'm not good at pointing out anything in particular really, so my little meager thoughts will have to do. ;) My apologies if I may have missed anything obvious lol, my mind's been scattered.

Here are the first three I have. I'll post the other ones later when I manage to write down something.

A Single Step [spoili]Slice of life, as I mentioned in the last MISC, is not really my cup of tea. However, I felt the story was written well enough, although I noted a couple of missing words, and a place where a word could have been replaced by another. I felt the quote usage was fine enough. I liked how the story delves into normal every day relationships and how even when you find out truths, everything doesn't automatically become hunky dory.
[/spoili]

The Promise of a Friend [spoili]I love poetry (even if at times I need to read it more than a few times to understand), so I very much enjoyed this entry. The story that was told was clear to me, and I couldn't help feel for the narrator, whom I'm presuming is Death. However, that brought a question to me. Why didn't the girl see the narrator as a monster like the other folks did?
[/spoili]

Passage to Piracy [spoili]
I will admit, it was hard to keep myself completely unbiased towards the story. I'm a huge fan of seafaring stories, especially those dealing with pirates and survival. The story immediately caught my fancy, and I loved the natural way the quotes were used, lots of props to that. It was quite interesting, seeing how Alison dealt with life at sea before being swept off to Davy Jones locker. I enjoyed reading the different settings she found herself in, kind of reminded me of Minecraft when you're dropped in an unknown world and have to make do.

What I would have like was if the punctuation was more on par. I felt some places needed periods while other places needed commas, the lack of which made it a little difficult to read. There were also some typos I took note of. One last thing that left me a little disappointed was the ending. This may be due to preference, but I felt it was rather sudden. Since it started with a grandmother relating a story to a child, I thought it would have been a more complete ending if Alison had returned to the actual present with her grandchild.
[/spoili]
 
  • Bucket of Rainbows
Reactions: Rae and KJDarKnight
Here are the remaining two!

The Devil's Christmas- [spoili]Anyone who's written with me or knows me well can agree to the fact that I'm not a big fan of angel/demon stories. Personal preference that put me off the story the first time I read it. However, the second time around, I had to admit that the author did a great job writing this story. I was confused by the transition the first time around, but the second time I read the story, I was actually rather impressed, enough that I literally smiled.

As for the writing itself, I don't remember seeing any typos or punctuation mistakes, or anything grammatical. That was something I noticed from the first time I perused the story. I also thought the quote was well used![/spoili]

Ripples- [spoili]This was well written. I liked the way the poem flowed for the reader, or at least for me. However (and this is probably because poems can be hard to understand), I found I couldn't quite picture what was going on. The ending was confusing for me. For example, who was 'he'? Of course, this has nothing to do with what I think of the writing, more my inability to understand poetry. I did very much enjoy the way the quote was used in the poem, so kudos![/spoili]

As always :D well done all of you! I can't wait to see who were the authors behind the different stories!
 
  • Bucket of Rainbows
Reactions: Rae
*flails arms* C'mon guys, let's have some more comments and reviews!

Especially authors ;) a test on how you judge yourself. That's always fun, eh?
 
Wait, wasn't there a comment here earlier from @KJDarKnight saying they would post their reviews tomorrow...? It's not here anymore, and there's no deleted indicator...
 
I also said something witty but helpful (I guess) and it's missing...
 
From Discord

We are back up. You may be missing your most recent posts due to the data loss, and we're sorry for the inconvenience. There shouldn't be further issues, but we recommend backing up important posts just in case!
 
Yes I did say I would post reviews lol. I am ony way home now to reread and write my reviews :)
 
Ok I am only going to review because there has been a lack of those this time. I wasn't going to because I am not much of a poetry fan, just my personal thing. For that reason, I'm not going to review the poems simply because I don't feel like I can be fair with them. (I'm sorry! If you're really dying for my opinion after all the voting is done etc... please feel free to message me and I'll do my best)

Ok so onward!

A Single Step
[spoili]
I'll be honest, slice of life type rps tend to bore me so I did struggle to read this, at first. HOWEVER! I did enjoy it because the characters were well written. I felt that I could relate to them as real people who are hurting. If a story can make me feel something, no matter the genre, it's automatically awesome! That's the goal of a writer, to create a bond between the reader and the characters and thereby evoking emotions. The author did that for me with the story and that's saying something because not many stories will do that. So, awesome job!! I am impressed with how real your characters are. In addition, it's not just the characters that were well done, the scene was well described and I easily found myself visualizing everything which is another key component to writing.

Over all, very well written!! I did enjoy reading it.

My only real issue was that it was very slow and seemed like a couple of small scenes were dragged out, but that's often the case with slice of life, which is not my preferred reading material. So personal preference there.
[/spoili]

The Devils Christmas

[spoili]

This one was written well, in the sense that the descriptions were engaging and made it easy to imagine. The usage of words was very good and transitions between paragraphs was easy.
That being said though, I was very confused right from the beginning. The character was on a mission, I could tell that much but what that mission was, I had no idea, I still don't really know.

I don't understand what the invisible thing attacking the character was or what was happening with that or why.... I'm finding myself struggling for what to say because I don't know what happened and don't understand the story.... maybe I missed something?

good job with the word usage, descriptions and overall writing skill. I think my issue was simply just that, my issue. Demon/Devil stories are not my thing either and maybe that's where I got lost.

[/spoili]

Passage to Piracy

[spoili]
Over all, I think that it was a well composed story with a cohesive begging middle and end. I loved the unique twist of Davy Jones Locker. The usage of actual nautical/ pirate terms was nice too and helped make it feel a little more real.
I also enjoyed the subtle transition from wimpy scared girl to pirate, and the nice little touch between the two main characters at the end. it was like, ok, she's good, she's going to survive being a pirate after all.
The death scenes were fun to read (because I'm terrible like that)

There were a couple of things I didn't like though. I didn't feel connected to the characters really. Maybe it's because romance is not my forte? Doesn't really appeal..... I wanted there to be more piracy and less romance haha. I would have loved to read more about life on a ship, I am totally fascinated with that and there wasn't a lot of that there. However, that wasn't the point of the story so personal preference there.

For what it was, I think it was very well done with potential to be even better

[/spoili]

Ok, there you go, authors, don't hate me D: This is just all my humble opinion as a reader.
 
Chirp chirp...
 
Read through all except for Passage to Piracy, which I skimmed simply because it was too long and I knew I wouldn't be able to get through it all before voting was closed with my sanity intact. Eventually Devil's Christmas got my vote because even though it was a little confusing at first, I wanted to say its pros and cons were the most evenly split. I am a moderately demonic reviewer, so I'm not going to post my reviews publicly here. Once voting's done and identities are revealed, if you wanna know my opinion, poke me directly. In PM or DM or some such.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Greenie
Pirates got my vote :) because pirates. And romance. And...pirates. But also because the concept was super fun and I thoroughly enjoyed reading it.

I'm not going to write reviews this time around...subjectively, none of the other stories were my jam and while they were well written, my reviews would essentially be too similar to justify taking up the writer's time!

Good luck! Can't wait to see the final results!
 
When is the voting actually going to be over? Tonight?
 
  • Useful
Reactions: Greenie